The Persistence Post: Why 'X Failures, 1 Success' Always Works on Reddit
Persistence posts work because they represent something most people privately believe about themselves: that if they just keep going, something will eventually break through. The data from r/SideProject and r/indiehackers consistently shows that posts framed as 'X failed attempts, finally one working' outperform straightforward success stories from the same authors. The reason is simple — the struggle validates the reader's own struggle, and the eventual breakthrough gives them permission to believe theirs is coming too.
Pattern Overview: Persistence
Average score
Best subreddits
When to use
When you have at least 3-5 genuine failed attempts before a success, and you can articulate what was different about the one that worked. Most powerful at 3-6 months after first traction on the successful project.
When to avoid
Do not use this format if the 'failures' were minor experiments (side projects you worked on for 2 weeks each) — the community expects real investment in each attempt. Also avoid if you can't explain what was genuinely different about the success — without that insight, the post is just a luck story.
Post structure
Title: The number of failures and what finally worked — be specific about both
The count: A quick inventory of the failed projects — names, what they were, why they failed
The pattern: What was going wrong across all the failures — the common thread
The breakthrough: What changed with the one that worked — and why you think it worked when the others didn't
Current metrics: Where you are now with the successful project — MRR, users, growth rate
What you learned about yourself: The meta-lesson about how you approach building, not just what you built
The honest admission: What part of you almost gave up and why you didn't
Real viral examples
39 is an almost absurdly large number that creates instant credibility. You can't fake 39 failed startups. The community knows the post will contain real insight about what separates success from failure at scale.
5 years is a long time. The combination of time and failure count represents a level of persistence most people would have given up on years earlier, which makes the eventual traction deeply satisfying to read.
The framing 'I finally understand why' is interesting because it positions this as a post about insight, not just success. This attracts readers at all stages — not just those who are struggling.
'Not doing that again' is a rare honest admission of a bad pattern. Most persistence posts celebrate the grind — this one questions whether the grind itself was a mistake, which creates a more nuanced and engaging discussion.
Generate this type of post automatically
RedditGrow analyzes your product and uses this framework to generate authentic posts that match your voice — then schedules and posts safely.
How to write this type of post
List the failed projects explicitly — names, duration, and why each one failed. Even a brief bullet list of 10+ failures is more impactful than describing them in abstract.
Find the common thread across your failures and name it clearly. 'I kept building products without talking to customers first' is more valuable than 'I didn't validate properly.'
Describe the successful project's early traction in specific numbers — first $1, first $1k MRR, first 100 users. The contrast with failure makes these milestones feel earned.
Write the meta-lesson about yourself as a builder — what this journey taught you about how you work best, what you avoid, what you're drawn to. This is often the most upvoted part of the post.
Include an honest account of the moment you almost gave up. The closer you came to quitting before the breakthrough, the more powerful this section is.
Share what you would tell yourself 5 years ago. This is the most directly actionable advice for readers who are currently in the struggle phase.
Common mistakes to avoid
Listing quick side projects (weekends, a few weeks) as 'failures' — real persistence posts involve projects you genuinely invested in for months. The community can tell the difference.
Making the final success too triumphant — persistence posts work because of the struggle, not the success. Don't let the success overshadow the journey.
Not explaining what was concretely different about the winning project — the pattern break is the entire value of the post. Without it, you have a persistence story with no lesson.
Pro tips
Explore more frameworks
Generate the Persistence post for your product
RedditGrow uses AI to craft authentic posts in this framework tailored to your product — and posts them safely across the subreddits where it performs best.